Young Earth Creationism and the Formation of the Sun


Young Earth Creationism (YEC) is a form of creationism that holds that the Earth and the universe were created by a direct act of God within the last 10,000 years, based primarily on an english literal interpretation of the Bible's Book of Genesis. This belief contrasts starkly with the scientific consensus, which places the age of the Sun at approximately 4.54 billion years ago.


Answers in Genesis (a YEC organization) says this:


“The nebular hypothesis is simply a story to describe what may have happened in the "prehistoric" solar system. There are no observations to support the claims that natural processes over millions of years could form a solar system.”

YEC and the Formation of the Sun

YEC proponents believe that the Sun, along with the rest of the universe, was created instantaneously by God during day four of the creation week described in Genesis. They reject the scientific model of stellar formation, which involves the gradual collapse of a molecular cloud under gravity over millions of years.

Scientific Understanding of Solar System Formation

Tau Protoplanetary Disk captured by the Alma Array


The prevailing scientific explanation for the formation of the Sun and the solar system is the nebular hypothesis. According to this theory:

  1. Molecular Cloud Collapse: A vast cloud of gas and dust, known as a molecular cloud, begins to collapse under its own gravity. This collapse may be triggered by events like a nearby supernova explosion.

  2. Formation of a Protostar: As the cloud collapses, it spins faster and flattens into a rotating disk. Most of the mass concentrates at the center, forming a protostar.

  3. Accretion Disk and Planetesimals: The remaining material in the disk forms a swirling accretion disk around the protostar. Dust and gas particles within this disk collide and stick together, gradually forming larger bodies called planetesimals.

  4. Formation of Planets: Planetesimals continue to accrete material, eventually growing into planets. The inner planets, like Earth, are primarily composed of rock and metal, while the outer planets are gas giants.

  5. Ignition of Nuclear Fusion: The protostar continues to contract and heat up. Eventually, the temperature and pressure at its core become high enough to initiate nuclear fusion, the process that powers the Sun.

Timeline of Solar System Formation

Based on scientific evidence, the formation of the Sun and the solar system is estimated to have taken tens of millions of years. Here's a rough timeline:

  • Collapse of the Molecular Cloud: This initial collapse may have taken a few hundred thousand years.

  • Formation of the Protostar: The protostar likely formed within a million years.

  • Accretion Disk and Planetesimals: The formation of planetesimals and the accretion disk likely took a few million years.

  • Formation of Planets: The planets, including Earth, likely formed within 10-100 million years.

  • Ignition of Nuclear Fusion: The Sun likely began nuclear fusion about 50 million years after the initial collapse of the molecular cloud.

Challenges to YEC

The scientific model of solar system formation is supported by a wealth of evidence, including:

  • Observations of young stars and protoplanetary disks: Telescopes have captured images of stars in various stages of formation, surrounded by disks of gas and dust.

  • Radiometric dating of meteorites: Meteorites, remnants from the early solar system, have been dated to around 4.56 billion years old.

  • Computer simulations: Sophisticated computer models can simulate the formation of stars and planetary systems, and these simulations align well with observations.

These lines of evidence pose significant challenges to the YEC perspective, which requires a much shorter timescale for the formation of the Sun and the solar system.

Conclusion

The scientific consensus is that the Sun formed over tens of millions of years through the gradual collapse of a molecular cloud. This timescale is supported by a vast amount of observational and theoretical evidence. YEC, on the other hand, proposes a much shorter timescale, typically within a few days, based on an english literal interpretation of the Bible. This view faces significant challenges in reconciling with the scientific evidence.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The "One-Way" Speed of Light is measured for the first time.

Image
Jeremiah 33:25 Thus says the Lord, 'If My covenant for day and night stand not, and the fixed patterns of heaven and earth I have not established, Job 38:19 "Where is the way to the dwelling of light?.. That you may take it to its territory And that you may discern the paths to its home? The observation of gravitational waves and gamma ray bursts from two neutron star–black hole coalescences in 2020 was a major breakthrough in astrophysics. It was the first time that gravitational waves and gamma ray bursts had been detected from such a system, and it provided new insights into the nature of these extreme objects. One of the most intriguing aspects of these observations is that they confirm the one-way speed of light. The speed of light is a fundamental constant of nature, and it is the same in all frames of reference. This means that, regardless of how fast you are moving, light will always travel at the same speed relative to you. The one-way speed of light has been tested
Read more

Distant Starlight and the Anisotropic Synchrony Convention: A Challenge from Neutron Star Mergers

Image
“As these neutron stars spiraled together, they emitted gravitational waves that were detectable for about 100 seconds; when they collided, a flash of light in the form of gamma rays was emitted and seen on Earth about two seconds after the gravitational waves .” The Anisotropic Synchrony Convention (ASC) is a proposed solution to the " distant starlight problem" encountered in young-earth creationism. It was proposed by Dr Jason Lisles of Answers in Genesis. This problem arises from the apparent contradiction between the young earth biblical age of the universe (thousands of years) and the vast distances we observe through telescopes (billions of light-years). The ASC proposes that the speed of light is not constant in all directions, but rather travels instantly towards the observer, explaining how we see light from seemingly young stars. However, recent observations of neutron star mergers present a significant challenge to the ASC.  In 2017, the LIGO and
Read more

The nebular hypothesis - a challenge to Young Earth Creationism?

Image
Psalms 90 : (written by Moses before Genesis) “ Before the mountains were born Or You gave birth to the earth and the world, Even from everlasting to everlasting, You are God. For a thousand years in Your sight Are like yesterday when it passes by, Or as a watch in the night.” Some recent Young Earth Creationists (YEC) posit that stars were created on Genesis Day 4 of creation as described in the Bible, using the 24-hour day interpretation. This implies that we shouldn't expect to find stars actively forming in the universe today . However, the nebular hypothesis , which proposes that stars and planets form from the gravitational collapse of giant clouds of gas and dust, is fully supported by scientific evidence.  Answers in Genesis (AiG) criticizes the nebular hypothesis over 700 times on their website. Their claims haven't been accepted by the scientific community as well as many many other Christians. On their website an article has the below illustration and
Read more