The Hermeneutic of Exclusion: Analyzing Young Earth Creationist Declarations on Inerrancy
The tension between modern scientific inquiry and traditionalist biblical interpretation has often culminated in formal "declarations." Among the most significant are the supplemental affirmations and denials produced by Young Earth Creationists (YEC) and flood geologists. These statements aim to close what they perceive as "loopholes" in broader evangelical documents, such as the Chicago Statement on Biblical Inerrancy. By examining these declarations—specifically those regarding scientific evidence and the nature of the Noachic Flood—one can identify a series of logical, theological, and scientific errors that underpin the YEC framework. The Epistemological Wall: Article IV The YEC declaration in Article IV establishes a hierarchy of knowledge that effectively renders scientific inquiry moot. By affirming that no evidence in history, archaeology, or science can be considered "valid" if it contradicts a specific interpretation of the scriptura...